Wayne Gretzky Bonnie Blair Tiger Woods Tiger Woods Roger Bannister Jack Nicklaus Michael Jordan Chris Evert Sandy Koufax Muhammad Ali Joe Montana
  Sportsman Front Sportsman Master List The Albert Alternative Where Stars are Born A Blow for the Republic Somebody's Gotta Do It The Best Column Ever* The Whammy of Sammy Sportsman of the Year Cover Gallery CNN/SI Front A Mark for the Ages Target: 61 McGwires Mighty 62 Multimedia

Your Turn: Any other Sportsman?

CNNSI.com users give their alternative 1998 Sportsman picks

Click here for more on this story

Posted: Friday December 18, 1998 05:43 PM

Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa were clear choices as Sports Illustrated's Sportsmen of the Year. But what if they weren't eligible? Who do you think would deserve the award? CNNSI.com users responded to the question, and here are a selection of answers:

Marion Jones , who had the best year any female sprinter has ever had. And she`s also the best long jumper in the world. She should be the clear choice even if Mac and Sammy were available.
-- Timo Toivonen, Turku, Finland

My Sportsman of the Year would be Doug Flutie . Above all he showed what a true athlete should be. He was happy to be the backup and when needed came in to perform his best. He understands the meaning of teamwork in never taking too much credit for his success and has not lashed out at all of those who shunned him all those years ago.
-- Michael Funk, Boston

Ricky Williams is by far the best even with Sosa and McGwire considered. He represents everything that is good not only in sports, but in human nature. I hope that he doesn't lose his humility and class as he enters the professional arena.
-- Kevin M. Fitzgerald, LaCrosse, Wis.

My Sportsman of the Year is not a person but a team. It is the New York Yankees , for the reason that there was not one standout player on the squad but the whole team was invincible and that is why they won 125 games.
-- Gary Berger, New York City

The easy choice would be Jeff Gordon , a guy who has won three Winston Cups, 13 races this year, and has done it all with class.
-- Craig Larson, Overland Park, Kans.

Definitely Alex Rodriguez ! Why? I've got 2 reasons ... 40 and 40! At 23 years old?! Can Mac & Sammy do that?
-- Loni Johnson, Federal Way, Wash.

Steve Yzerman (center, captain, heart and soul) of the Detroit Red Wings is the epitome of a true sportsman. In leading the '97-'98 Wings to their second Stanley Cup Championship, he has proven that he is truly one of the greatest hockey players to ever set skate on the ice. I would hope that he received some consideration for this award.
-- Scott Simnitch, Plainfield, Ill.

John Elway : He made several Super Bowls with lackluster teams for years and finally won the Holy Grail. Not only that, but he has led his team to an amazing record this year and possibly another Super Bowl victory. Nothing was sweeter than finally seeing the Lombardi Trophy in the hands of one of the greatest quarterbacks the game has ever seen.
-- Jason Homorody, Columbus, Ohio

Wrestler Stone Cold Steve Austin . Yes that's right, Steve Austin -- what athlete brings in more money and has a greater impact on the sports world today? Of course I could have recommended Michael Jordan, but the NBA is another story. I know, you are reading this and probably laughing, but here is a guy who has worked his way up to the top and has won the hearts of literally millions of fans throughout the world. He demonstrates dedication to his profession as well as any other athlete. He has overcome great adversity and has changed the sport of wrestling. I ask you, "Who has had a greater impact in any other sport?" This is why I recommend Steve Austin for the Sportsman of the Year award.
-- Dean Clark, Houlton, Maine

Davor Suker , Striker and Golden Boot winner from Croatia at World Cup France 98. He led the underdog Croatian team to a 3rd-place finish at the World Cup. He led them to what many people thought was impossible due to fighting in his homeland, and also won the golden boot along the way. He truly showed himself as a sportsman when he refused to take credit for his team's fine showing, saying instead that his teammates deserved all the credit.
-- Wes Faulk, Savannah, Ga.

Cal Ripken. He reached the one true unreachable star, and ended his streak on his terms and to benefit his team. He didn't get hurt and he probably could have gone another 400 games. He did so with such never-before-seen modesty and class that I think he deserves to be 1998 Sportsman of the Year.
-- Paul Gardner, Baltimore

Tennessee women's basketball coach Pat Summitt , for an undefeated season, a sixth title, and the job of molding Chamique Holdsclaw into one of the greatest players in college ball, male or female. And for turning down the pros to stay with a college program "because young women need to see that we can succeed at this level."
-- Patricia Miller, Madison, Wis.

Dominik Hasek would have been a great choice. He almost singlehandedly took the Czech Republic hockey team to the gold medal in the Olympics. He took the Sabres on his shoulders and almost carried an otherwise mediocre team to the Stanley Cup finals. And he won a second consecutive Hart Trophy as the league's MVP, something unheard-of for a goaltender. Simply put, there is no other athlete in his or her sport (other than that Jordan guy) who can carry their team as far as the Dominator can!
-- Mike Elliott, Lower Allen, Pa.

What Chris Spielman did -- give up a season (at least) while he's still one of the better players in the league, to help his wife fight cancer -- definitely merits recognition. Despite all the dysfunctional sports families you write about, Spielman gives proof positive that there are athletes worth caring about.
-- Mark Cohen, Pittsburgh

My Sportsman of the Year would be Mark O'Meara . The reasons are simple: no holdouts, no contract disputes, no trash talk, just two majors and a lot of class. Thank you Mark, for being someone my kids can really look up to.
-- Lyle Boerchers, Laurier MB, Canada

Bryce Drew . The primary reason nobody cares whether the whiny NBA players or owners ever settle their deal. We all know college basketball is much more exciting and fun to watch than the NBA!
-- Jeff Richied, Houston

Not Sportsman, but Sportsmen. Major League Baseball did more for itself this year than in the history of baseball. From Ricky Henderson leading in stolen bases to Juan Gonzalez's historic run at the RBI crown to young A-Rod's 40/40 season to second-year man Nomar Garciaparra's MVP run, baseball has shown that it is our national pastime again. It grabbed us by the heart and made us proud to say, Let's go out to the ballgame.
-- Dow Pender, Winston Salem, N.C.

There's no other choice: You guys did it absolutely right. Big Mac and Slammin' Sammy are indeed perfect choices!! Good job.
-- Brent Lansden, Beaver, Okla.

 
Related information
Multimedia
Click here for the latest audio and video
Search our siteWatch CNN/SI 24 hours a day

Sports Illustrated and CNN have combined to form a 24 hour sports news and information channel. To receive CNN/SI at your home call 1-888-53-CNNSI.

Copyright © 1999 CNN/SI. A Time Warner Company.
All Rights Reserved.

Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.