CNN Time Free Email US Sports Baseball Pro Football College Football 1999 NBA Playoffs College Basketball Hockey Golf Plus Tennis Soccer Motorsports Womens More Inside Game Scoreboards World
EVENTS
MLB Playoffs
Rugby World Cup
Century's Best
Swimsuit '99

CENTERS
 Fantasy Central
 Inside Game
 Multimedia Central
 Statitudes
 Your Turn
 Teams
 Cities

AD PARTNERS

  Power of Caring
  presented by CIGNA


SPORTS ILLUSTRATED
 This Week's Issue
 Previous Issues
 Special Features
 Life of Reilly
 Frank Deford
 Subscriber Services
 SI for Women

FEATURES
 Trivia Blitz
 Free Email

TELEVISION
 CNN/SI - TV
 Turner Sports

SHOPPING
 CNN/SI Travel
 Golf Pro Shop
 MLB Gear Store
 NFL Gear Store

SI FOR KIDS
 Sports Parents
 Games
 Buzz World
 Shorter Reporter

SITE RESOURCES
 About Us
 myCNN
 
Inside Game

Peter King's Super Bowl Diary: Friday

Here's why I'm voting for LT to make the Hall of Fame

Click here for more on this story

Posted: Friday January 29, 1999 01:59 PM

 

Notes of the Day | 10 Things I Think I Think

MIAMI -- Last call for Lawrence Taylor .

As one of the 36 selectors for the Pro Football Hall of Fame, I've made my views on Taylor's candidacy known on this site, in the magazine, on CNN's Sunday morning football show, on CNN/SI, and, this week, on 957 talk shows going live from the Super Bowl. But I'm practicing my contributions for Saturday's selection meeting, so bear with me.

When I signed up five years ago to be a Hall of Fame selector, I agreed to abide by the rules of the Hall. Those rules, in part, say: "The only criteria for selection to the Pro Football Hall of Fame is a nominee's achievement and contribution as a player or coach or contributor."

 
The 36 selectors (almost all are sports writers; one comes from each of the 30 NFL cities, and six, including me, are at-large selectors) will gather at the Hyatt Regency here Saturday at 8 a.m. to discuss who makes the Hall this year. We will sit at tables that form a large square, and we will consider each of the 15 finalists in due turn. At the end of the day, between four and six people will be elected to the Hall. In effect, everyone who makes it must have no more than seven "no" votes from the committee -- unless fewer than four men qualify that way. Then, those men with the most votes (a minimum of four each year) will be selected.

Several of my brethren on the committee, according to published reports, will not vote for Taylor because of his cocaine problems and his total lack of remorse for them. I believe keeping Taylor out of the Hall for his wasteful and stupid lifestyle is wrong. I believe the only thing that counts is what a player did on the field -- the bylaws tell us that -- and Taylor is a first-ballot, slam-dunk Hall of Famer. My mother and father taught me that whatever you do in life, you've got to play by the rules, whether you like them or not. I may not like these rules. Jim Rome asked me this week on the radio what I'd do if O.J. Simpson was up for Hall membership right now. I told him I'd have to do one of three things: I'd have to vote for him, because his was obviously a Hall of Fame career. Or I'd have to try to get the bylaws changed. Or, because I believe he killed two people, I'd have to resign, because I couldn't vote him in and thus couldn't carry out my duties as a selector.

I think I'd do the third -- resign -- in Simpson's case if confronted with it.

But in Taylor's case, I don't have to make the choice. I covered Taylor for four years in the 1980s as a Giants' beat man for Newsday. I didn't like him. I thought he was a bully and a people-user. But was he the best defensive player of his day? Certainly. In history? Maybe. Now, he hurt himself and five people -- his ex-wife and four kids -- with his drug use. He hurt the Giants by being suspended for four games in 1988 because of substance-abuse. That's the only place I can find that he ever had an adverse effect on his team.

In his annual Friday-before-the-Super Bowl press conference, commissioner Paul Tagliabue spoke eloquently about whether he thinks Taylor should be elected Saturday. "I think he should, and I say that without qualification," Tagliabue said. "I've given that a lot of thought. The Hall of Fame is about performing on the field. Lawrence Taylor changed the way the game is played." And he said maybe this would be a spur for Taylor to get his life together.

Maybe. Maybe not. Doesn't matter, at least as far as the vote goes.

Drugs are a scourge on our society. But they are should not be a factor when I mark my "X" beside Taylor's name Saturday morning.

I just hope there aren't eight who disagree with me Saturday morning.

Notes of the Day

IDIOTIC COLUMN NOTE OF THE DAY IN WHICH I'M STICKING UP FOR MY COLLEAGUE:

In this morning's Miami Herald, columnist Dan LeBatard promotes Lawrence Taylor for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. The 36 voters (I'm one) are supposed to judge Taylor on his playing merits only, not his off-the-field problems, and LeBatard, rightfully, says the 36 ought to keep their righteous noses out of it and vote only on Taylor the football player, not Taylor the addict. And he writes: "When did Sports Illustrated's Paul Zimmerman get the right to judge character? Wasn't that supposed to be God's job?"

Dan, other than me, there is no greater advocate for Taylor in that group than Zimmerman, who has urged from debate one on this issue to leave the personal crap out.

WEIRD SUPER BOWL NOTE OF THE DAY:

Because four Bronco wives are expecting and near their due dates, the team brought an obstetrician on the road trip here.

Now for Today's 10 Things I Think I Think:

1. I think Chris Chandler's going to have the ball in his hands at the two-minute warning around 10 Sunday night, with the game in his hands.

2. I think I wondered where all the stars were last night. I sat in the Pelican Bar on South Beach Thursday night and watched the world go by, and Carnell Lake was the biggest name that walked by in the parade of humanity. Unless, of course, you count Toi Cook .

3. I think the Falcons have spent most of the week preparing for the Broncos to blitz heavily in this game, and I think they're right. Steve Atwater's coming from everywhere Sunday.

4. I think I will miss doing tonight what I did a year ago on Friday night at the Super Bowl, when I dined at Top of the Cove in LaJolla, Calif., with the Brett Favre party. He had the medallions of antelope. I had filet of ostrich. His was better.

5. I think I was glad to hear Paul Tagliabue say this morning that he thinks replay will be back come March. The league has no choice. Their officials, and their integrity, are getting beaten over the head eight or 10 times a year, and all of America watches it over and over on highlight shows.

6. I think Tagliabue wants to change the hiring process that has resulted in no new black coaches in the NFL being hired in the last 36 months. But I've said it before and I'll say it here right now: The league office shouldn't be the target for all the justifiable verbal firebombs. the owners who ignore black candidates should. "You need affirmative action, but you don't need affirmative action that builds in false preferences," Tagliabue said.

7. I think the thing that surprised me, and the media throng at the Tagliabue press conference this morning, was his strong stand that Eddie DeBartolo will not regain control of the 49ers in 1999. I'd heard all along that DeBartolo would trade all of his outstanding DeBartolo Corp., stock to his sister, Denise DeBartolo York , sometime early in 1999 in exchange for the team. A lot of people in the media and public, not just me, had heard Eddie would be back at the controls soon. "I don't know who those people are," Tagliabue said, "but they don't include me." Touche.

8. I think the funniest issue that came up this morning with Tagliabue when a Mexican reporter asked if the NFL might set a rotation system for each team to play a game overseas, say, every five or seven years. "I think we'll get there eventually," Tagliabue said, which surprised me. In 2035 maybe. Imagine Tagliabue picking up the phone, calling Bill Parcells and saying: "Coach, a little change here. Your first game this fall is in Osaka." Now THAT would give Parcells a new heart condition.

9. I think I have nothing left to say. Nothing except:

10. I still think Denver wins, 26-21.

Click here to send a question or comment to Peter King's Mailbag.

 
Related information
Stories
Peter King's Super Bowl Diary: Thursday
Peter King's Super Bowl Diary: Wednesday
Peter King's Super Bowl Diary: Tuesday
Peter King's Monday Morning Quarterback
CNN/SI's Super Bowl XXXIII Coverage
Multimedia
Click here for the latest audio and video
Search our site Watch CNN/SI 24 hours a day

Sports Illustrated and CNN have combined to form a 24 hour sports news and information channel. To receive CNN/SI at your home call 1-888-53-CNNSI.


To the top

Copyright © 1999 CNN/SI. A Time Warner Company.
All Rights Reserved.

Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.