Return to CNN/SI Main Page
 

 

Referees step to forefront

Officials overshadow action with red cards

Click here for more on this story

Posted: Thursday June 18, 1998 09:12 PM

  Referees have responded to criticism from FIFA with more red cards, five of which were handed out in Thursday's matches (AP)

ATLANTA (CNN/SI) -- The first week of the World Cup was filled with color from the teams, the fans, seemingly everyone except the referees. Thursday the officials lashed out with a color of their own -- red.

Five red cards were handed out in the two matches as the referees responded to criticism from FIFA the only way they could, by enforcing the rules and enforcing them strongly.

Denmark and South Africa, who played to a 1-1 draw, had to finish the match with just 19 players, and France lost its captain Zinedine Zidane when he decided he was going to step on a South African player who attempted to tackle him.

The Zidane call was a no-brainer, but the other four red cards Thursday were calls that might not have been made four years ago in the last World Cup. For that matter, they might not have been made three days ago if not for complaints from FIFA and Michel Platini that referees were ignoring the new edict to give red cards to players for dangerous tackles from behind.

This will certainly remain a hot topic over the next few days at the least. The severity of a tackle is a judgement call and one that referees seemed to be doing a good job on before FIFA waded into fray. Now, with referees worried that FIFA will not use them again if they do not enforce the edict, are we going to end up with red cards in nearly every game?

The fortunate thing Thursday was that the red cards did not significantly affect the action on the pitch. The France game was a blowout regardless, and both goals had been scored in the Denmark-South Africa draw when Colombian referee John Jairo Toro Rendon got red card happy in the last 25 minutes of the match.

That's not to say the two referees' actions will not play a big role in who advances from Group B. Five players will not suit up for their teams when the four squads return to the pitch for the final two first-round matches, which will no doubt change coaches' strategies, and players are certain to be more cautious in an attempt to make sure they do not pick up a red card.

If the players on all 28 teams begin playing differently Friday because of Thursday's actions, then FIFA has gained what it wanted -- more offensive-minded soccer. But what are the chances of that? That remains the big question along with the matter of whether or not referees will continue to hand out red cards at a record pace.

But enough of the officials, let's get back to the actual action in Thursday's games, which saw France lose two valuable players in its blowout of Saudi Arabia and provided South Africa with its first finals goal ever.

As discussed earlier, France lost Zidane for its final group match when the midfielder picked up a red card late in the second half of France's 4-0 romp past Saudi Arabia. The bigger loss for the French, though, came in the first half when striker Christophe Dugarry had to leave the game with a strained right hamstring. He will likely miss the next game, and those injuries tend to linger, leaving Dugarry's status for the rest of the tournament in doubt.

Not that the French have had trouble scoring anyway. They lead the finals with seven goals in two games. Thursday, it was the young guys turn to provide the scoring. David Trezeguet and Thierry Henry, both 20 years of age, scored three of France's three goals, and continued to answer their countrymen's question of where would France's offense come from.

France is now assured a spot in the second round, and, providing it does not lose to Denmark, it will take the top spot in Group B. Saudi Arabia, meanwhile has zero points after two games and can make plane reservations to go home after its match with South Africa.

Denmark's 1-1 draw with South Africa leaves the South Africans clinging to a slim hope of getting into the second round. For that to happen, South Africa would have to beat Saudi Arabia and Denmark would have to lose to France, and the aggregate scores of those two games would have to erase South Africa's three goal differential it currently trails Denmark by.

Not likely.

Still, it was nice to see the joy which South Africa brought to this finals after years of being left out for political reasons. The South Africans will be back, and they will only get better in time.

Player of the Day: Thierry Henry. The 20-year-old French lad tallied two goals against Saudi Arabia, picking up the slack when Dugarry went out in the 28th minute with a hamstring pull.

French fears over who will score for their country have been assuaged in their first two games with Henry scoring three, leaving him tied for the World Cup lead.

Goal of the Day: Benedict McCarthy. South Africans have waited seemingly forever for McCarthy's score, their country's first in finals play.

Running onto Shaun Bartlett's backheel touch pass, McCarthy slotted the ball between Danish goalkeeper Peter Schmeichel's legs, and the celebration was on. McCarthy ran to the corner flag, and did his little dance before being mobbed by his teammates. It was a refreshing moment to see a black man score a goal in World Cup play for South Africa.

Quote of the Day: "The referee killed the game." -- South Africa's Benedict McCarthy discussing the Denmark-Saudia Arabia game which had three red cards

Outlook for Friday: Return to Group D, otherwise known as the group of death. Spain will be desperate for a win when it takes the pitch against Paraguay. A loss would likely eliminate the Spaniards, and there's no telling if their passports would still be valid when they attempted to cross the border.

While more talented than Paraguay, Spain must patch up the holes in its defense that led to three Nigerian goals if it hopes to come out with a win.

The other match features the deliberate Bulgarians against the always attacking Nigerians, who just a week and a half ago were trying to fire their coach -- Bora Milutinovic.

It seems Milutinovic wanted the Nigerians to play a more defensive, less go for broke style of football, and if there is one thing the Nigerians do, it is go for broke. Their two goals in the last 20 minutes against Spain were evidence of that.

A wise man would not get near the Nigeria-Bulgaria match when picking one of Friday's games, Spain is such an easy pick over Paraguay. Then again, a wise man doesn't pick Saudi Arabia to draw with France.

So, a bold pick is needed to erase those bad memories. The pick for Friday is Bulgaria and not because Nigeria has only played well once over the past month.

No, Bulgaria will knock off Nigeria because it has a capable offense, and an impressive defense. Go with Bulgaria 1-0, setting up a mess in Group D.  

Related information
Stories
91st minute: Chile wearing hard luck label
3 red cards color draw
Stats
World Cup Real-Time Scoreboards
Multimedia
Click here for the latest audio and video
Message Boards
The color red!
Were all the cards deserved? Did FIFA step too far? Tell us what you think on the CNN/SI World Cup Message Board!
Click here for more

Search our siteWatch CNN/SI on cable 24 hours a day

Sports Illustrated and CNN have combined to form a 24 hour sports news and information channel. To receive CNN/SI at your home call 1-888-53-CNNSI.


To the top

Copyright © 1999 CNN/SI. A Time Warner Company.
All Rights Reserved.

Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.